Monthly Archives: April 2013

The real Reason for Gun Conrol

What is gun control

At last, the gun control debate is beginning to gain some traction. For a very long time it seemed all gun control articles were only about the 2nd amendment and “the right to bear arms.” Now however, the tide is changing. More and more articles are revealing the gun control statistics, and these are making people wake up.

In 2010 there were almost as many deaths by gun as death from traffic accident. That is shocking. Not enough articles reenforce these gun control statistics. However, focusing too much on deaths diminishes the real significance. For every one person killed by a gun THREE are wounded. If there are thirty thousand deaths there are on hundred thousand injuries!

Three times as many wounded as killed. There is a good gun control statistic for people to remember.

The real reason we need gun protection laws, aka gun control, is because Americans can’t be trusted with guns. Gun violence is not about drug dealers shooting one another, it is about drunk angry men shooting their wives or girl friends. Gun protection laws are about slowing domestic violence. Gun control is about protecting women.

What is gun control about? This; guns do only one thing. They kill. That is their sole purpose. We make students go to drivers education for hours and hours and hours because we want our roads to be safe FOR ALL OF US. We need to do the same thing about guns. Many people who own guns have them for the worst reasons. They live in a safe neighborhood and claim they need a gun for “protection.” That’s like wearing a football helmet for fear of bird poop. It makes no sense.

This isn’t said much in gun control articles but the real reason men want guns is because it converts their sense of self from powerless to powerful. Most guys slog through life with little or no control over much. A gun in the hand gives them the power of life and death. Think of any other thing that does that.

Tags: gun control statistics, gun debate, US gun control statistics

The Fallacy of the 2nd Amendment Part 2

Gun control statistics

Part 2 (Continued)

It wasn’t hard for the marketing agencies of the weapon’s industry to create ways to motivate these men (and the very rare woman.) The industry set out to characterize any effort at gun control as an attack on the cowboy myth of the Old West. They worked with this concept shaping it to various audiences and and arguments. The elevated and made “real” the myth that guns settled America. The worked diligently to weld an association between manliness and a self perception of manliness. They built the new myth of the American man…to be a man meant to own a gun. Anybody without a gun was not a man.

The continued domestic upset in America during the seventies helped the gun industry, now being fronted by the NRA. As America became stratified by the war and its lingering animosities, it was easy to portray those who “obeyed” government as righteous and those who opposed government policies as anti American (Remember, “America Love it or Leave it!”) From there, it was very easy for the marketers to attach patriotism to guns. From then on the new, modern American gun mythology was spread. Real men supported the government, real men were patriotic, real men owned guns.
The emotional attachments the weapons industry needed were now in place. Guns were not about killing, they were about being a strong, macho patriotic American MAN.

Of course, any rational evaluation of these childish sentiments turns the argument into laughable mush but in America belief systems are manufactured by industry. Our entire economy is based on the freedom of advertisers to create myths and persuade consumers to associate themselves with them. “Good moms use Tide!”; Busy dads show their children love by sharing Frosted Flakes with them; College educated women still need magic enzymes in their guts that only Activa can provide.
America is built upon marketing myths. It is the fuel that drives our economic engine. The weapons industry, through the NRA, has found a way to legitimize a disreputable fantasy and convert it into a patriotic, macho American myth for men.

There is only one way out.

All the rest of us, all the Americans who don’t believe that a gun is a badge of independence, or patriotism, or manhood, have to step forward and say so. It must be said forcefully however. The rest of us must reclaim the turf held by these myths. We have to change the story. We have to control the gun control debate: guns are not patriotic, men solve problems with their minds not with guns; people who believe that guns solve problems have a treatable mental disorder and, finally, Americans don’t need guns at all. We are safe here.

TAGS: gun control debate, gun control statistics, gun control article, 2nd amendment, gun control debate, right to bear arms, what is gun control, cowboy myth, gun control debate, gun control, control debate, patriotism, gun control article. Second amendment, gun control article, freedoms, gun control debate, constitution, gun control debate.

The Fallacy of the 2nd Amendment Part 2

What is gun control

Part 2 (Continued)

It wasn’t hard for the marketing agencies of the weapon’s industry to create ways to motivate these men (and the very rare woman.) The industry set out to characterize any effort at gun control as an attack on the cowboy myth of the Old West. They worked with this concept shaping it to various audiences and and arguments. The elevated and made “real” the myth that guns settled America. The worked diligently to weld an association between manliness and a self perception of manliness. They built the new myth of the American man…to be a man meant to own a gun. Anybody without a gun was not a man.

The continued domestic upset in America during the seventies helped the gun industry, now being fronted by the NRA. As America became stratified by the war and its lingering animosities, it was easy to portray those who “obeyed” government as righteous and those who opposed government policies as anti American (Remember, “America Love it or Leave it!”) From there, it was very easy for the marketers to attach patriotism to guns. From then on the new, modern American gun mythology was spread. Real men supported the government, real men were patriotic, real men owned guns.
The emotional attachments the weapons industry needed were now in place. Guns were not about killing, they were about being a strong, macho patriotic American MAN.

Of course, any rational evaluation of these childish sentiments turns the argument into laughable mush but in America belief systems are manufactured by industry. Our entire economy is based on the freedom of advertisers to create myths and persuade consumers to associate themselves with them. “Good moms use Tide!”; Busy dads show their children love by sharing Frosted Flakes with them; College educated women still need magic enzymes in their guts that only Activa can provide.
America is built upon marketing myths. It is the fuel that drives our economic engine. The weapons industry, through the NRA, has found a way to legitimize a disreputable fantasy and convert it into a patriotic, macho American myth for men.

There is only one way out.

All the rest of us, all the Americans who don’t believe that a gun is a badge of independence, or patriotism, or manhood, have to step forward and say so. It must be said forcefully however. The rest of us must reclaim the turf held by these myths. We have to change the story. We have to control the gun control debate: guns are not patriotic, men solve problems with their minds not with guns; people who believe that guns solve problems have a treatable mental disorder and, finally, Americans don’t need guns at all. We are safe here.

TAGS: gun control debate, gun control statistics, gun control article, 2nd amendment, gun control debate, right to bear arms, what is gun control, cowboy myth, gun control debate, gun control, control debate, patriotism, gun control article. Second amendment, gun control article, freedoms, gun control debate, constitution, gun control debate.

The Logic of Gun ControlWhat is Gun Control

Gun control statistics

What is gun control all about? Too often gun control articles are driven by an irrational argument. The gun control articles that dominate newspapers, magazines and public debate almost always revolve around the 2nd amendment. However, the right to bear arms is essentially irrelevant.

Why is it? Two reasons 1) The right to own guns is established and 2) the right to regulate guns is equally well established. In other words, let’s not debate what is already decided. That’s not what gun control is about.

If that’s true than why are so many gun control articles only about the 2nd amendment? The answer is that the gun control debate is still controlled by the gun lobby. This lobby, as we all know, is fronted by the NRA. It is the NRA that has defined the boundaries of the debate and will not permit the discussion to wander toward real issues. By making the debate about nothing, it avoids being meaningful. It boors readers rather than enlightens them. What is gun control about, maybe just sleight of hand.

What is really important in the gun control debate? What should gun control articles be about? To start, they should address statistics. The gun control statistic that is most surprising to many Americans is the number of deaths caused by guns compared to the number caused by traffic accident. They are almost equal! In 2010, the last year for data, there were 33,687 traffic deaths and 31,672 gun deaths (CDC.)

Here are other important gun control statistics: there are an estimated 300 million guns in America, not including those owned by the military. How many does the military own? About 4 million. There are 75 times more guns owned by private citizens than the army, navy, marines, coast guard, air force and Special Forces combined.

So where do we begin a meaningful gun control debate? Maybe we begin by asking “What are we afraid of that we need all those guns?” After that we might ask, “How did we come to feel such fear in ‘The Greatest Country in the World?'” If we are strong, why are we so frightened?

So we are left with this “What is gun control really about?” Is it about the constitution is it about facts. What is gun control if not a genuine debate about our contemporary culture? What is gun control except a profound, national self inspection?